News

Silicone has become a go-to material for food contact items and baby tableware, thanks to its flexibility, durability, and reputation for safety. From baby plates and bottles to spoons and teething toys, silicone is everywhere—but how safe is it really?

The answer depends on where in the world it’s made and used. Global standards for silicone in food contact and baby products differ widely, and understanding these regulations is key to ensuring safety, especially for infants.

We’ll dive into the silicone safety standards of the United States, European Union, Germany, China, and Hong Kong. Let’s get started!

Why Silicone Safety Matters

Silicone’s popularity in kitchens and nurseries stems from its heat resistance, non-stick properties, and softness—perfect for little hands and mouths. However, its safety isn’t guaranteed unless it meets rigorous standards. Poor-quality silicone can leach harmful chemicals like volatile organic compounds (VOCs) or heavy metals into food, posing risks, especially to babies.

That’s why countries have developed regulations to control what’s allowed in silicone products. But these rules aren’t the same everywhere, and some places enforce stricter guidelines than others. Whether you’re a parent shopping for baby tableware or a manufacturer aiming to meet global demands, knowing these standards can make all the difference.

A Global Overview of Silicone Regulations

Let’s break down how five key regions regulate silicone for food contact and baby products. Each has its own approach, ranging from detailed laws to reliance on international guidelines.

• United States: FDA and CPSIA Guidelines

In the U.S., the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) oversees silicone under 21 CFR 177.2600. Silicone must be "Generally Recognized as Safe" (GRAS) for food contact, but there’s no specific limit on chemical migration. Testing is often voluntary, using methods like gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) to check for harmful substances. For baby products, the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) steps in with the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA), banning phthalates and other toxic chemicals. While this provides a safety net, the lack of detailed migration limits leaves some gaps compared to other regions.

• European Union: Broad Rules with Room for Improvement

The EU regulates food contact materials under Regulation (EC) No 1935/2004, requiring them to be safe and not transfer harmful substances into food. Silicone doesn’t have its own specific EU law, but the Council of Europe’s ResAP(2004)5 guidance sets a migration limit of 10 mg/dm². Testing methods like EN 1186 and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) ensure compliance. Starting January 2025, a ban on bisphenol A (BPA) in food contact materials will tighten safety further. However, some EU countries—like Germany—go beyond these baselines with stricter rules.

• Germany: The Gold Standard for Silicone Safety

Germany’s BfR Recommendation XV is a standout in silicone regulation. It sets a 10 mg/dm² migration limit and caps VOCs at 0.5%, making it one of the toughest standards worldwide. Detailed testing, including headspace GC-MS for VOCs and migration tests, ensures compliance. For baby tableware, this strictness offers extra peace of mind, positioning Germany as a benchmark for safety.

• China: Strict and Structured Standards

China’s GB 4806.11-2016 standard governs silicone in food contact items, matching the EU and Germany’s 10 mg/dm² migration limit. It also sets a lead limit of ≤ 1 mg/kg and requires a Quality Safety (QS) certificate for compliance. Testing involves methods like inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) for metals and gravimetric analysis for migration. This structured approach makes China’s standards robust, especially for baby products.

• Hong Kong: Relying on Imports

Hong Kong lacks specific silicone regulations under its Consumer Goods Safety Ordinance (CGSO). Instead, it leans on international standards from places like the EU or U.S. Testing is ad hoc, often using GC-MS based on import rules. A 2021 Hong Kong Consumer Council study exposed the risks of this approach, pushing for local rules as a 2025 plastics ban nears.

The Hong Kong Consumer Council Study: A Wake-Up Call

In September 2021, the Hong Kong Consumer Council tested 14 silicone products, and found troubling results. Nine exceeded Germany’s 0.5% VOC limit, with some reaching 1.4%. High VOC levels, like those from siloxanes, can pose health risks—think potential liver damage or respiratory irritation—especially for infants. The study underscored Hong Kong’s regulatory gap and sparked calls for local silicone standards.

Comparing Silicone Standards: A Side-by-Side Look

To see how these regions stack up, here’s a detailed comparison of their silicone regulations:

Key Takeaways from the Comparison

Migration Limits: The EU, Germany, and China enforce a 10 mg/dm² cap, while the U.S. and Hong Kong don’t specify one.

VOCs and Chemicals: Germany’s 0.5% VOC limit is unique and strict; China adds a lead cap.

Testing: Germany and China mandate detailed methods, while the U.S. keeps it voluntary, and Hong Kong’s approach is inconsistent.

Which Standards Are the Strictest and Safest?

Stringency: Germany Takes the Lead

Germany’s BfR Recommendation XV stands out as the most stringent, thanks to its dual focus on migration (10 mg/dm²) and VOCs (0.5%). The thorough testing requirements make it a tough hurdle for manufacturers but a win for safety. The EU and China follow closely, with clear limits and structured testing, while the U.S. and Hong Kong lag due to less specificity.

Safety: Best Bets for Everyday Use

For general food contact and baby tableware, products meeting German, EU, or Chinese standards are the safest bets. Their clear limits and mandatory testing reduce risks of chemical leaching. U.S.-made products can be safe if they align with stricter imported standards (e.g., EU or German), but the lack of local detail is a weak spot. Hong Kong’s reliance on imports leaves safety up to the source—highlighted by the 2021 study’s findings.

For infants, where safety is non-negotiable, opt for items certified to German, EU, or Chinese standards. These offer the best protection against VOCs, heavy metals, and other contaminants.

What This Means for You

When shopping for silicone baby tableware or food contact items, check for certifications. Look for labels like “BfR-compliant,” “EU-approved,” or “GB-certified” to ensure top-tier safety. Avoid vague claims like “food-grade” without proof of testing, especially for infants. If you’re in Hong Kong, prioritize products from brands meeting German or EU standards until local rules catch up.

Wrapping Up: Your Guide to Safe Silicone Choices

Silicone safety varies widely across the globe. Germany leads with the strictest standards, followed by the EU and China, all offering robust protection for food contact and baby tableware. The U.S. and Hong Kong, while safe under certain conditions, rely on broader or imported rules—leaving room for improvement, as Hong Kong’s 2021 study showed. For the safest silicone products, especially for babies, stick to items certified to German, EU, or Chinese standards. By understanding these regulations, you can make informed choices that keep your family safe and healthy.

At Cushcush, we prioritized the use of food grade silicone which can pass the Germany standards, in our tableware collection. It's our promise to design and give your little ones the best we can.